Redeemer Lutheran ChurchRedeemer Lutheran Church

Nativity

The story of our annual tradition

Historic newspaper clipping on scrapbook paper showing Redeemer's Living Nativity: shepherds, Mary, Joseph and the Magi in costume around the manger beneath a straw-roofed stable, with a live donkey and sheep grazing in the foreground

The Living Nativity has been an annual tradition ever since Redeemer Lutheran Church first presented it to the people of Bayside in 1964. With the assistance of a donkey and some sheep, approximately 30 members and friends of Redeemer appear in the 20-minute pageant, walking through the narrated story of the birth of our Savior, Jesus Christ.

Now running for over 60 years, the pageant has seen its share of tribulations, beginning with the 1965 escape of Whitey the donkey (who was rescued from the LIRR tracks), through all sorts of bad weather, and through the only time we were forced to cancel due to COVID restrictions.

It has been a source of joy and inspiration to all who have participated. Thousands have gathered on our sidewalks to watch the beautiful pageant; many have written or called to say how beautiful it was to pause during the busy holiday season and witness this telling of the true meaning of Christmas.

In the words of an anonymous donor to our GiveSendGo fundraising campaign: "A BAYSIDE INSTITUTION. CHRISTMAS IS NOT COMPLETE WITHOUT WATCHING THIS BEAUTIFUL PAGEANT. I hope it runs for another 160 YEARS. My mother was an Angel up on the roof nearly 50 YEARS AGO. It was a cold and blustery December, and the Angels nearly slipped on the way up to the roof, but the warmth of Christ and the promise of Christmas to come made it all possible. GOD BLESS BAYSIDE."

May God bless us all.

Newspaper clipping titled Tale of a Donkey: Whitey the burro being led from the Bayside police station by the Rev. Ernest Pflug, his daughter Dawn, and Richard Paar, and Whitey back in the Nativity tableau with Carolyn Paar and Raymond Clarke as Joseph and Mary
Long Island Star-Journal, December 22, 1965
A choir of angels in white robes and tinsel halos lit up against the night sky during the 2013 Living Nativity